This blog shares opinions, regional news, views and stories related to beautiful Botswana and some of its neighbouring countries. Special emphasis is given to tourism in Botswana and the amazing affordable vacation and safari packages that are currently on offer in the country. IT'S SO EASY... you should try it sometime!

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

Only 6 signatures – how successful was the Botswana Elephant Conference?

"Current elephant poaching in Africa remains far too high, and could soon lead to local extinctions if the present killing rates continue."
Image by: Reuben Goldberg

By Clarissa Hughes - 24 December 2013

In the wake of the Elephant Summit held in Botswana in early December where urgent measures to halt the rampant illegal ivory trade were adopted one is left asking if it is enough?

Against a backdrop of ever increasing levels of poaching across Africa the Summit was called to tackle the onslaught that threatens this iconic species. Statistics released at the summit indicate that 22 000 elephants were poached in 2012, an improvement on the estimated figure of 25 000 elephants poached in 2011, however ivory seizures in 2013 signal that elephant deaths in 2013 may reach 40 000.

“We have gathered to secure demonstrable commitment to undertake those measures that have been deemed urgent across range, transit and consumer countries,” said H.E Lieutenant General Seretse Khama Ian Khama, President of the Republic of Botswana, at the official opening of the Summit.

Attended by high-level officials from African elephant range states, including Gabon, Kenya, Niger and Zambia, ivory transit states of Vietnam, Philippines and Malaysia and ivory destination states, including China and Thailand the meeting has been hailed a success. However, it is reported that only six of the countries represented signed the agreement at the Summit, the other representatives requiring higher approval.

Of the fourteen urgent measures adopted by the meeting the most important one involves classifying wildlife trafficking as a ‘serious crime’ – a move that will unlock international law enforcement co-operation provided for under the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime.  This co-operation includes mutual legal assistance, asset seizure and forfeiture, extradition and other tools to hold criminals accountable for wildlife crime.

Other measures agreed to include engaging communities living with elephants in their conservation, strengthening national laws to secure maximum wildlife crime sentences, mobilizing financial and technical resources to combat wildlife crime and reducing demand for illegal ivory.

As with all good intentions implementation is key.  

While some countries are ramping up enforcement, both in protected areas and at their ports and borders, others have increased the penalties for poaching or ivory trading. Awareness programmes aimed at reducing both the demand and the illegal supply have also gained momentum. Earlier this year, CITES provisions were strengthened, with the eight countries most involved in the large-scale ivory trade, developing and implementing concrete action plans, which should be completed by June 2014.

But is this enough?

The three drivers of the ivory trade are demand, governance and poverty.  While Africa is making great strides towards improving governance and reducing poverty if demand is not addressed, poaching will continue.

“Despite several NGOs campaigning to reduce demand in consumer countries the push needs to be led by those countries’ governments to be effective,” said Jason Bell, Program Director and Elephants Regional Director, South Africa for the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW).  “Unfortunately there is no apparent effort on the part of the Chinese government in this area,” he added.

With much of sub-Saharan Africa’s tourism industry being nature-based the preservation of wildlife is of paramount importance to the livelihoods of millions of Africans. One in twenty jobs in sub-Saharan Africa is in tourism.  According to the World Bank’s Africa Tourism Report 2013 there are 5.3 million people directly employed in the industry with a total direct/indirect employment impact of 12.8 million.  The World Travel and Tourism Council forecasts that by 2022 these figures will be 6.8 million and 16 million respectively.

Futhermore it is acknowledged that the trade in illegal ivory is funding rebel militias in many parts of Africa. Militias that not only kill, rape and pillage, but also undermine the economic growth of the continent. Think Al Shabaab in Kenya, M23 in the DRC, the Seleka in CAR and Joseph Kony in Uganda.

If all this seems far removed from the shores of South Africa think again.

JSE listed companies have been expanding into Africa over the last decade.  MTN and Shoprite spring immediately to mind and there are many others. The Standard Bank of South Africa is largely owned by Chinese nationals.  The connection between restricting Africa’s economic growth, by encouraging the demand for illegal ivory, and thwarting Chinese interests is therefore very easy to make.

“We are now starting to hear global resonance of the message that the elephant poaching problem is a serious problem for all,” said Jason Bell.

The surge in legal commerce of all other types between Africa and Asia must surely open the door to negotiating agreements on wildlife products. 

To borrow the phrase of the President of Botswana what we need is ‘demonstrable commitment’ to the cessation of the illegal wildlife trade.  For Africa and Asia to thrive we need Asian governments to lead campaigns to address the demand for wildlife products in their countries.

Sourced from:

Related Post: Poaching critical as Botswana opens Elephant Summit

1 comment:

  1. I wish all involved success in saving the beautiful animals .


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Popular Posts

Wanda Wolmarans (L) & Adriaan Barnard (R)
e-mail: | Website: | Skype: wollaw